Dead people

Dead people really piss me off. The way they just keep being dead, and they never relent, no matter how hard you beg. They're just so stubborn. My mother was stubborn while she was alive too. In fact, I think that's why she's dead.

Nine years ago tonight she got knocked down by a car. My mother got run over. She got knocked off her bicycle. She was cycling home and got hit by a car. She was involved in a terrible accident. What do any of these words reveal about what happened? They don't reveal. They hide. They tell, but they hide.

On the one hand, it is true. You have a woman who was riding along on a bicycle who then wasn't riding along, because she was flying through the air and landing in the gutter. And the thing that stopped her riding along was another car, and that other car was moving.

But what I'm thinking of tonight, nine years on, is this:

I'm thinking of the woman on her way home from work. She's riding her bicycle from West Kensington to Earl's Court. There's just one road left to cross. It's Cromwell Road - the A4 - London's spine.

(Who here knows Cromwell Road? Then you know).

The crossing she rides up to has a red bicycle and a green bicycle, in addition to the red man and the green man. It's December, it's dark, it's 8 o'clock. What does she do?

Who knows - she's dead, so we can't ask her.

That might be the ultimate truth, and she was my mother, and I would love to hear her side. But there were witnesses. I heard them. At the inquest. Everyone said, and the coroner concluded, that she had tried to ride across the road when the bicycle and the man were red. I didn't have any trouble believing that conclusion, but I was ashamed of it for many years. I didn't tell anyone about it until two years ago.

"Random accident." Who in this city hasn't crossed a road when the man was red? 

But I don't think it was random. I think it was typical of her. And that's why I'm angry. My neck hurts. I'm vibrating.

We were always cycling, my mother, my sister and I. We cycled to school, first in Hammersmith, and then in Fulham. We cycled everywhere. And every time, my mother put the fear of death in me. The fear of her death. "Please," I would say, "be more careful." And every time she dismissed my worry, "Well I've got this far, haven't I?" She suffered from the illusion of immunity and that's what killed her. That, and impatience.

She was not a person who liked to wait. For anything. And I think she lacked a magical sense of the precariousness of life. I think that killed her too.

It wasn't random.

Impatience and the illusion of immunity.

I am angry.

It doesn't matter how happy I am. Every year the anniversary destroys me. Every year I have the sense that I am waiting for something terrible to happen. My whole body tenses as though I, and not she, am about to be hit. And whose fault is that?

I did a cost benefit anaylisis. It didn't take long:

  • Cost of waiting for lights to change: one cold and boring minute
  • Benefit of waiting for lights to change: not dying
  • Cost of not waiting for lights to change: being dead forever*
  • Benefit of not waiting for lights to change: getting home a minute sooner

* (the list is actually endless, and is still growing today)

I want to say this. If there is something you can easily do that will increase your chances of not dying, please do it. If you're at the lights and it's a dark night, and the road is big, then wait. If the zebra crossing is a hundred yards away, walk to it. Put your seatbelt on before you drive off. Be late and alive rather than on time and dead. Do not talk on the phone or fiddle with the stereo while driving. Are you in such a hurry that you will risk being dead forever? Or killing someone else? Forever? I couldn't understand it before she was dead, and I understand it even less now.

For the love of life, if you are going to die, let it be for a good reason!

People I speak to, they say, "she's a part of you", "she'll be in your heart forever." But that's not how I feel tonight. I feel angry and empty. When people are dead it means that they are dead. That's what it means.

Einav says I'm too hard on my mother. She says everyone does it, people relax when they get close to home, they take chances they wouldn't normally take. And I think of my stubborn, impatient mother, as she approaches the crossing. And I say: "Really? Cromwell Road. 8 o'clock on a dark December evening. You couldn't have waited for the lights to change?"


This is the crossing. Picture it pitch black. Picture it tonight. You're almost home. Would you wait for the lights to change?

On Being a Motherless Mother

"Mummy, when your mum died, did she have bones?

Matan is four. So let's turn that macabre question into an opportunity for education!

"Yes. But everyone has bones, not only dead people. Come here, let me show you. These are your bones, can you feel that? If you didn't have bones, you wouldn't be able to stand up. You'd be all floppy, and wobbly like jelly. Show me what you would look like if you didn't have bones."

He crumples onto the floor. I crumple too.

"But mummy, where did your mummy die? I mean where? Do you know where?"

"You mean which road? It's called Cromwell Road, near Aunty Olivia's house."

"Do you know exactly where? Will you show me?"

"Yes, I'll show you."

"But mummy. Mums look left and right, don't they?"

Which is worse? To tell a child that grown-ups don't always do the right thing, or to tell them that doing the right thing won't always protect you? Either answer is crushing, and four is too early to be crushed like that. The clock of his attention span starts ticking loudly. "But mummy, they do, don't they?"

"Yes, my darling. Mummies look left and right. It's very important to look left and right. I always look left and right. I'll always be here for you. I love you." Inside I hope that my bluff remains flesh for as long as he needs me. We cuddle, but I can't tell which of us is squeezing tightest.

Yesterday evening, Maya, who is two, found a photo of my mother in an old chest of drawers. My beautiful, twenty-year-old mother. My mother in the life she had before me, in the hands of my daughter who came after she was gone. Only our navels bear fleshy testimony to this sad game of generational tag.

In the photo, her face is turned slightly to the side and illuminated from the right. It was taken in a professional studio, in black and white, and printed on the kind of heavy matt paper used by people in the days when photos meant something. It's the first time I've ever seen it. By the date scrawled on it, I work out it was taken just after she left my two-year-old half sister with her ex-husband's parents, and then moved to London alone, masquerading as single and unencumbered. Not a trace of that story can be read on her face. I'll never know why that photo was taken, nor why then. Some questions no longer have anyone alive to answer them.

Holding the photo, Maya is running towards me in the way that only toddlers do. Everything urgent, everything important, everything new.

"Mummy, is the car coming to get her?" she asks, and I can hear a note of concern in her small voice.

Two months shy of her third birthday, she has no intimation of the exhaustible and non-repeatable nature of time. No linearity, no 'then', only the NOW of the NOW. Still strong in her is that prelapserian ignorance that, growing up, we shed. Her question immediately makes me think of Roland Barthes (hey, my two-year-old is a prodigy!). Looking at the 47-year-old photo, I say to myself: My mother is dead and she is going to die. The car has come and it is going to come.

"Mummy, can you put the photo where we can see it?"

"Ok my darlings, but not in the bedroom." (This unexpected superstition embarrasses me, even in front of myself).

Later, I lie down in between them in the bed they share. "Sing us your mummy's song," they say, merrily. I start stroking their little heads, thinking that if we can all just stay alive for long enough so that none of our deaths is obscene, then I do not need anything else in this world.

Show me the way to go home / I'm tired and I want to go to bed.

I can't believe it's me who's doing the stroking.

Where is my mother's hand?

The Body was that of a Well-Nourished Caucasian Female

On 13th December 2005 I was rehearsing with the Bulgarian Choir at the embassy in South Kensington. Bulgarian choral music employs unique harmonies and the voice is projected through the head, often adopting a tightened soft palate, rather than through the chest. It’s more than mysterious, and very enchanting. Being a part of that sound, as in a choir, you feel like your whole body manifests the vibrations of the music. After the rehearsal I started making my way to the tube, when my sister called. Did I know where Mum was? “Probably at bridge, tap or Japanese,” I said. She was always busy, with hobbies or friends. I thought nothing of it until my phone rang again, this time as my train was pulling out of Westminster station and I momentarily had reception. It was my sister again, but the line broke off as we entered a tunnel. My stomach sank.

As soon as I got out of the station at Swiss Cottage, I called my sister. She asked me if I was on the way to the hospital. What did she mean, ‘on the way to the hospital?’ Hadn’t Einav told me, she asked, about the accident? Accident?!? She explained. My mother, who rode her bike to and from work, had been involved in an accident and was now at St George’s Hospital in Tooting. I ran home and Einav and I called a taxi to take us there. Over the course of the journey I spoke to my sister several times and each time received a new splinter of information. She was being operated on. They didn’t know how serious it was. Her pelvis was broken. No, not broken, shattered. (At this I burst into tears). The journey took an agonising 45 minutes. When we finally got to casualty at St George’s we were led through to a special room where my sister was waiting. Nobody visiting a relative in casualty wants to be led through to a special room. A nurse came through and led us upstairs to the ward near the operating theatre where they were working on my mother. I asked the nurse how my mother was doing. The nurse mentioned head injuries. New information all the time. Stone-heavy drips of new information. No one was smiling. When we got upstairs we were led to another special room and shortly afterwards two policemen joined us. The 12 hours we were to spend in that room were some of the worst of my life. Until about 4am we had no idea whether she was going to live or die and, if she were to live, how life-changing her injuries would be. We waited - Einav, me, my sister, and the Police Family Liason Officer, Steve Bates. Like a special room, no-one wants to be assigned a Police Family Liason Officer. One of the policemen with Bates asked if these hours could be counted as overtime. How disparate our concerns were at that moment and in that place, when all we wanted was the news that she was alive, that we could see her, could talk to her, could hold her. 

We spent the night at turns crying, at turns numb, going for aimless walks around the deserted hospital car park, pondering the various possible outcomes. It is not possible, in words, to describe how horrible it was to wait in that room all night. I've never felt so lost, so like a hostage. At one point I remember announcing, in tones aimed mostly at convincing myself, that whatever happened we would have to cope. We would have to cope. At around 3.30am my father arrived with food that none of us could eat.

“It’s extremely unlikely that she’s going to make it.” 4am. Two surgeons sat down on the low sofa next to us, sporting well-rehearsed airs of gravity. Their hands had been inside my mother. “Extremely unlikely.” She was bleeding, and they could not stop it. 

The sight I saw in the ICU was horrific. She was no longer tall, solid, strong and vivid. She was shrunken, pale, and hunched up on the pillows in a posture that I have never seen anyone assume in conscious life. All around her and coming in and out of various orifices were tubes, wires and machines. She was surrounded by medical personnel who were working furiously at tending to her, keeping what was left of her alive. The blanket over her body was raised high around the area of her pelvis, where a large cage was holding her splintered body together. I approached my mother, who became at once both the person whose face I knew best in this world, and at the same time, a stranger. I held her hand. It was cold and limp. A puncture wound where a cannula had been was bleeding. No, not bleeding, dripping. Pouring. The blood, no longer able to clot, was simply falling out of her body and onto mine. I came up close to her, still holding her dripping hand, and began to speak. People say that the sense of hearing is often the last to go, but I will never know whether she heard what I said and I doubt that she did. What remained of her at that stage was less than a shadow. I told her I loved her and that I would try and live as she had taught me. That was all I said, but I repeated it many times over in several different configurations, repeating it as though the length of my speech could keep her alive. And then I said goodbye. I left, washed her blood off my hands and went back with Einav to the special room.

Looking back I’ve often wondered why we didn’t spend the whole night sitting at her side. At the time, it just didn’t seem to have been an option. Was it because the medical personnel were too busy, encircling her with their procedures and devices? Was it because the doctors who liaised with us didn’t really present it as an possibility? Was it because of the uncanny attitude of passivity that we collectively adopted in that room, the sudden onset of impotence and lack of agency? Or maybe we just didn’t want to? Had she been conscious, I would have been there. Maybe if there had been some hope of her surviving, I would have been there. But she didn’t have a hope and I wasn’t there for her. She gave me entrance into this world and I failed to accompany her departure.

As soon as the nurse came into the special room it was obvious that my mother was dead. I don’t remember her words, all I remember is how young she was, and that she was crying. And at that point a fire alarm went off, as though speaking on our behalves. It was loud, like our pain. And it was a protest. But it was cruel, because it was routine, and it would come to symbolise what everyone learns when they lose someone they love. That even as people die, daily life continues oblivious, nonchalant and mundane. Nothing but an 8am fire alarm drill at a south London hospital.

The journey home took us through unchanged London streets and onto the tube, whose passengers were going to work even though my mother was dead. We arrived home, shaking from the adrenaline of sleep deprivation, and the shock of a changed world. And then it hit me. Someone had killed my mother. And worse, that bastard had defined her last moments, and had somehow shared them with her. By killing her, he had become an important person in her life. Perhaps he had been the last person to have seen her alive.

Einav and I moved to my mother’s house, where my sister still lives, and together we instinctively sat a kind of shiva . We slept in my mother’s bed, which still had her smell. Visitors came, sat with us, brought food. I constantly had the feeling we were waiting for something, but for what? For her to walk through the door? For the pain to pass? It was the most torturous wait I have ever endured, and yet there was nothing to wait for anymore.

The police family liaison officer told us what had happened that night. My mother had been killed on a pedestrian/cycle crossing on the A4/Cromwell Road. She had landed in the gutter not 50 yards from home. The man who hit her, in his Alfa Romeo (why is it that details matter?), had not been a bastard at all, but a kind man, a surgeon on his way home from a hospital shift. His light had apparently been green, hers red. Colours have never had such a heavy meaning. It was some years before I could accept what this meant: that my mother had perhaps been reckless, and responsible in some way for her own death; and it took even longer for me to become angry with her on that account. The surgeon had got out of his car, administered first aid, and held her head while waiting for the ambulance. That she got to spend the last few moments of her conscious life in his presence is a great comfort. When we met him at the inquest, I hugged him and said, "I know it wasn't your fault."

In those early days, I blamed not my mother, certainly not the surgeon, but the road itself. The senselessness created such a vacuum; I had to fill it. Obsessively I traced the road on maps of London, noticing the way it ruthlessly sliced through the west of the city, splitting it into two pieces and gathering momentum until it reached Earl’s Court where it wantonly swallowed up my mother. Every part of that road had been responsible. Its delta of estuaries: Sloane Street, Fulham Road, Kensington Road, Old Brompton Road, Queen’s Gate, Gloucester Road, and, worst of all, Earl’s Court Road were all tainted with her blood. But most guilty of all was its source - Hyde Park Corner, which, like a demonic heart, relentlessly pumped traffic like blood, and cars like platelets into this artery of death.

I wish I had not gone to identify her body. In some way I thought that seeing her would help mitigate the denial element of grief. But now I think it was a mistake. Her best friend, Mark, accompanied me to the mortuary at St George’s, where we were met by the assistant coroner, a young, slight man with a necessarily serious manner. He led us into the room where she - or, at least, her body - lay on a gurney, covered up to the neck with a crisp white sheet. The room had a very particular smell, a mixture of sweetness and chemicals such that I have not smelt anywhere else. Her skin was pale and waxy. Employing heavy use of a gel or cream, someone had styled her hair in such a way as I had never seen her wear it in life. This made me cross, to see that she had been touched and handled in an intimate way by strangers who now knew her in a way she would never know them. There were some scratches and grazes on her face, but nothing too horrific. What was horrific was her absolute stillness. No matter how deeply a living person may try to enter into a meditative state, no matter how motionless a comatose patient may appear to be, nothing approaches that state of stillness achieved by a dead person. It was not merely the lack of physical movement or breathing that I perceived there in that room, watching my mother. What I saw was the total absence of the humming vibration of life, as though I could sense that the blood under her skin was stagnant. The configuration of her mouth, the way it lay in her face like an open gash, at once taut but also slackened, epitomised this unholy stillness. Mark kissed her on the forehead, but I couldn’t, and we left. I didn’t know then that I would later have flashbacks of my mother lying dead on the gurney, and that those flashbacks would also include the smell of the room where she lay.

A week after she died, I cried ugly like a baby, screaming "Mummy" and stamping my foot as though a tantrum would bring her back. 

I miss my mother so much.  Sometimes I feel that I'm her, especially when I'm relaxed, and I can feel her looking through my eyes.  It's as though through loving someone we consume them and they can't possibly leave.

“The body was that of a well-nourished Caucasian female in her fifties.” The first line of the autopsy report said more about how absurd, how wrong her death was than anything. A doctor friend of mine read through it with me and explained the parts I couldn’t understand. I learnt about body parts I didn’t know existed. My mother was so badly injured by the accident, said my friend, that, had the surgeons known about the extent of the damage before going in, they would not have bothered. Fast metal versus soft flesh is an inequitable fight.

What was left of her - her eyes and her heart valves - we donated. Someone somewhere is walking around with them. I hope.